Sunday, Nov 15 | --:--
Back to home

Thousands March in Edinburgh Against AI Data Centres, Demand Say on 23 Scottish Proposals

An estimated 6,000 people, by organisers' count, marched down Edinburgh's Royal Mile to the Scottish Parliament on November 14 against large AI data centres, backed by more than 80 groups. Friends of the Earth Scotland says there are 23 proposals that together would add 9.1GW of peak demand, against about 5GW today, and wants a public consultation and a pause before approvals. The Scottish government says it will publish data centre planning guidance before the end of the year and already requires impact assessments above 50MW. The demand figures are campaigners' calculations.

3 min read Edinburgh, Scotland View as Markdown
A procession of ochre and teal umbrellas, with no people under them, winds down a generic cobbled hill toward a vast plain teal box sitting in open fields; no company logos.

Scotland's pitch for AI data centres has met organised opposition before most of them have a planning decision. Thousands of people marched down Edinburgh's Royal Mile to the Scottish Parliament on Saturday, November 14, demanding a public say before any large AI data centre is approved. The fight is no longer only about one site at a time: campaigners want a national consultation on the whole pipeline, while the government says the planning system can handle it.

The march and the demand#

An estimated 6,000 people took part, Friends of the Earth Scotland senior campaigner Kim Pratt told the Edinburgh Evening News; the group's own release says "over six thousand." The BBC described the turnout as thousands. More than 80 organisations backed the march, including local campaigns, climate groups, trade unions and anti-poverty charities, organisers said, and it was part of a wave of European protests against data centres timed to a global day of action during the COP31 climate talks.

Campaigners are asking the Scottish government to hold a public "national conversation" on AI data centres before any are approved, and Pratt said they want a pause on current developments. Some marchers came from communities facing specific plans, including Cockenzie in East Lothian, Larbert in Falkirk, a 200MW proposal at Hermiston in west Edinburgh, and Chapelcross in Dumfries and Galloway, which at a planned 1,000MW would be one of the largest data centres in the world, according to the BBC. Scotland's biggest existing site is thought to be DataVita's 12MW facility in Airdrie, the BBC reported.

What the numbers claim#

Friends of the Earth Scotland says there are 23 proposals of different sizes and stages. By its calculation, all of them would add 9.1GW of peak demand to Scotland's current 5GW, roughly tripling it; its campaigner also said they would "double Scotland's electricity demand." Those are campaign figures, and many of the proposals may never be built. The Scottish Greens and campaign groups have called for a moratorium on large data centres, the BBC reported.

The Scottish government said it will publish new planning guidance on data centres before the end of the year and is "developing a strategic approach to maximising the public benefit" from them. Planning authorities must now notify ministers of new applications, and any data centre above 50MW must submit an environmental impact assessment, a spokesperson said. Innovation Minister Alyn Smith has called data centres "the whisky bonds of the AI sector."

The march lands as Britain courts gigawatt projects elsewhere, such as the plan for an AI data centre at Drax Power Station in North Yorkshire. In Scotland, the question being forced is who decides whether the power and land go to AI.

Limits#

  • Turnout is the organisers' estimate; we have seen no police figure.
  • The 23 proposals and the 9.1GW total are Friends of the Earth Scotland's count and calculation, and its release also uses a "double" framing; we have not checked each proposal's status or size.
  • This was a protest and a set of demands. The Scottish government has not announced a pause or consultation.

Sources#

Prior Coverage

Earlier Times of AI reporting on this thread.

Scroll to continue reading