Judge Lets DRAM Conspiracy Suit Proceed Against Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron Over HBM Pivot
US District Judge Noël Wise on November 14 denied Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron's joint motion to dismiss a proposed class action alleging they conspired to cut supply of conventional DRAM such as DDR5 while shifting capacity to high-bandwidth memory for AI accelerators. She found the complaint plausibly alleged an agreement under the Sherman Act, pointing to hard-to-reverse moves such as long-term HBM lock-ups, fab delays and near-identical customer vetting, and rejected AI demand as a sufficient innocent explanation at this stage. Nothing has been proven; answers are due December 7.

The memory makers' best defence for soaring DRAM prices has been the AI boom itself: everyone wants high-bandwidth memory for accelerators, so capacity moved there. A federal judge has now said that explanation is not enough to end a lawsuit. On November 14, US District Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California denied a joint motion by Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron to dismiss a proposed class action that accuses them of conspiring to restrict supply of ordinary DRAM while shifting wafers to HBM. The ruling is about plausibility, not proof, but it means the AI memory pivot will be examined as possible coordinated conduct rather than only as market forces.
What the court decided#
The docket shows the order denying the motion to dismiss was signed and filed on November 14, a day after a 27-minute hearing. Judge Wise found that the complaint plausibly alleged an agreement in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act, and that the case was not a rerun of the earlier "DRAM II" suit the Ninth Circuit dismissed in 2022, LitNews reported from the order. "The Court finds that it is not," she wrote.
The suit, filed on June 25 by 17 consumers and small businesses from five states, alleges that the three companies controlled more than 91% of global DRAM revenue as of the third quarter of 2025, cut production from late 2022 and from 2023 shifted capacity to HBM, which the complaint says "requires approximately three to four times the silicon wafer area per gigabyte compared to conventional DDR5 DRAM." It alleges conventional DRAM prices rose 171.8% in a year and 697% over 18 months, while none of the three meaningfully expanded commodity capacity. These are the plaintiffs' allegations, accepted as true at this stage.
The judge said a pivot to HBM alone "might not be sufficient," but that related conduct tipped the analysis, according to LitNews: long-term contracts locking in HBM supply, reported refusals of long-term deals with big conventional DRAM buyers, Micron's December 2025 decision to close its Crucial consumer brand, delayed or halted fabs, and DDR4 wind-downs in the same quarter. She said near-identical customer-vetting practices the three allegedly adopted in January 2026 "strongly support a plausible inference of conspiracy," and rejected the companies' "obvious and non-conspiratorial explanation" of AI demand, noting the vetting began after the boom and the HBM pivot were under way. Answering the companies' point that rivals in concentrated markets "watch each other like hawks," she wrote that the allegations "are more akin to hawks flying in formation."
Why it matters beyond the courtroom#
The same HBM business has been the engine of record results. SK Hynix passed 100 trillion won in quarterly revenue on server DDR5 and HBM4, and Samsung's record quarter came almost entirely from chips. The suit asks whether the conventional-memory shortage that came with that shift was an independent response to AI demand or something the three agreed. The court gave no weight to investor talk of "supply discipline," conference meetings or the three-firm market structure, LitNews reported, so the case now rests on the business decisions themselves.
Limits#
- A motion-to-dismiss ruling only tests whether the allegations, taken as true, are plausible. No court has found that the companies conspired, and they can contest every allegation.
- We saw the docket entry but not the order itself; quotations from the order and the complaint come from LitNews's report.
- The price figures are the plaintiffs' allegations. The companies have argued that AI demand explains their conduct.
Sources#
- CourtListener: Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., 5:26-cv-06345 (N.D. Cal.), docket entries 66-68 (November 13-14, 2026)
- LitNews: Judge refuses to dismiss DRAM supply conspiracy suit against Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron (November 14, 2026)
- Wccftech: Federal judge rejects memory makers' defense to advance class-action antitrust lawsuit (November 15, 2026)