Sunday, Nov 22 | --:--
Back to home

UN Weapons Talks End Without a Treaty Mandate on AI-Driven Autonomous Weapons

The 128 states party to the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons ended a week of talks in Geneva early on November 21 by agreeing to 'elaborate' an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems over two years, with experts reporting to a 2028 meeting. They did not agree to negotiate a legally binding treaty, which nearly 100 states had sought. Diplomats quoted by the Guardian and POLITICO blamed Russian objections, and said the US, UK, Israel and others also resisted binding rules.

4 min read Geneva View as Markdown
A handmade editorial collage on torn ivory paper in ochre and teal: a long paper conference table, seen at an angle, with ochre-kraft edges and a torn teal runner down its length, stands among a row of empty chairs on both sides; one blank unsigned ivory sheet lies in the middle of the table, and a plain folded paper glider hovers just above the sheet, casting a soft shadow on it; no logos.

The world's main forum for regulating weapons that choose their own targets has bought itself two more years of talking. States party to the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) ended a week of talks in Geneva in the early hours of Saturday, November 21 without a mandate to negotiate a legally binding treaty on lethal autonomous weapons systems. They agreed instead to "elaborate" an international instrument, with a group of government experts to report to a meeting of the parties in 2028.

What was agreed#

The CCW decides by consensus, so any one of its 128 parties can block a decision. The Guardian reports that the push for a negotiating mandate collapsed just before 5am after all-night talks failed to overcome Russian objections. POLITICO, which saw the final decision, says it proposes to "elaborate" an instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems "in the context of international humanitarian law" and does not mention a legally binding instrument.

Julien Thöni, the Swiss diplomat who chaired the conference, said some countries had rejected the word "negotiate," AFP reported via Al Jazeera. He described the outcome as a significant step after more than ten years of talks, and said the process should determine which weapons can be banned under international humanitarian law and which can be permitted but regulated.

Nearly 100 countries had spoken in favour of negotiating a binding ban on fully autonomous weapons that can kill without a human giving the final order, Swiss news agency Keystone-SDA reported. A bloc of seven, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama, had pushed for a treaty to be negotiated within one year, according to the Guardian.

Who resisted#

Diplomats quoted by the Guardian and POLITICO said Russia blocked formal negotiations through procedural objections, but it was not alone. Two EU diplomats told POLITICO that the US, the UK, South Korea, Japan, Turkey and Israel also resisted binding regulation, and a Brazilian diplomat said "some people are hiding behind Russia." The Guardian reports that the US delegation said human control over autonomous weapons had come up when Donald Trump met Xi Jinping at the APEC summit this week; at that meeting, Xi said AI should always remain "under human control", but the US was reluctant to commit to a binding treaty.

Campaigners were scathing. Nicole van Rooijen, executive director of the Stop Killer Robots coalition, called the mandate "watered down" and said autonomous weapons, including systems that use AI to choose targets, are already being deployed in combat. Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch called the outcome disappointing. Rain Liivoja of the Asia-Pacific Institute for Law and Security told POLITICO that, with no mention of a binding instrument, it remains "possible — likely, even — that there will be no treaty by the end of 2028."

Why it matters for AI#

The talks were about weapons, but the question underneath is how much targeting judgment can be handed to software. That question is no longer hypothetical: this week evaluator Vals reported that frontier chatbots marked civilians as targets in simulated tests once the task was framed as a game. Our read: with the only standing UN forum now committed to a non-binding process until 2028, any near-term limits on AI in the targeting cycle will come from national rules, procurement terms and the developers' own usage policies, not from a treaty.

Limits#

  • We did not obtain the CCW's final decision text; its wording is as reported by POLITICO and the Guardian.
  • Accounts of which states resisted come from unnamed diplomats quoted by the Guardian and POLITICO; those governments' own statements were not reviewed.
  • The talks ended before this edition's window; we include them because the outcome sets the international track for military AI until 2028.

Sources#

Prior Coverage

Earlier Times of AI reporting on this thread.

Scroll to continue reading